The 2026 Thanksgiving Pie Pickup will be TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 24 and WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 25 from 10am-3pm at The Blue Star restaurant - 1645 S Tejon Street, Colorado Springs - across from Ivywild School.Sweeten Your Celebration!
thanksgiving
PRE-ORDER
BUY 7 PIES
GET 1 FREE
All pies must be one flavor.
Sweeten Your Holidays with
Pies, Cookies and Treats!
Let Gold Star Bakery handle dessert for your holiday feast with our signature pies and delightful cookies and bars. Looking for the perfect gift? Take advantage of our BUY 7 GET 1 FREE deal and give the gift of pie!
PRE-ORDERs
Thanksgiving pies will be available for pick up ONLY on Tuesday, 11/24 and Wednesday, 11/25 from 10a-3p at The Blue Star restaurant - 1645 S Tejon Street, Colorado Springs, CO 80905 - across from Ivywild School.
Pre-orders are due by Monday, November 16, but may be turned off if our baking capacity is reached before then.
2026 THANKSGIVING
QUESTIONS? See the FAQ below ↓ or Contact Us.
Flavors
PIE Pre-oRder FAQs
-
Our Thanksgiving pie menu is:
Bourbon Pecan
Tart Cherry
Dutch Apple
Salted Maple
Classic Pumpkin
GF Bourbon Pecan
GF Tart Cherry
GF Dutch Apple
GF Salted Maple
GF Classic Pumpkin
-
Gluten
Gluten free options are available for all flavors. Crust, filling and topping will all be gluten free.
Dairy
All of our pies contain dairy.
Eggs
Pumpkin, Bourbon Pecan, and Salted Maple all contain eggs. GF crust also contains egg.
Disclaimer
All sweet treats may contain or come in contact with common allergens such as dairy, eggs, wheat, gluten, corn, soybeans, tree nuts, nuts, peanuts, fish, shellfish, strawberries, cinnamon and bananas.
-
Thanksgiving pies will be available for pick up ONLY on Tuesday, November 24, 2026 and Wednesday, November 25, 2026 from 10am-3pm at The Blue Star restaurant 1645 S Tejon Street, Colorado Springs, CO 80905 - across from Ivywild School.
-
Email us at info@goldstarbakery.co and we’ll get back to you as soon as we can.